A quiet garden path curving through trees in soft, warm light

Reflections

The Day I Stopped Trying to Think My Way Through It

What understanding can't always give us.

November 16, 2026

I've spent much of my life believing that if I could just understand something well enough, I could figure out what to do about it. Give me a challenge, and my mind goes to work. I consider the possibilities, examine what happened, imagine conversations that haven't taken place, and try to anticipate what might happen next. I look for patterns, consider different perspectives, and wonder what I might be missing.

And when I don't find an answer, I usually think some more.

For much of my professional life, that approach has served me well. As an educator, administrator, consultant, and coach, I've relied on my ability to think critically, solve problems, and help people navigate complicated situations. I've always been curious about why people do what they do and what makes meaningful change possible.

Thinking has been one of my greatest strengths. But somewhere along the way, I began noticing that the same mind that helped me solve problems was sometimes making it harder for me to find peace with the ones I couldn't solve. I started wondering whether thinking and understanding were always the same thing.

When Thinking Becomes a Way of Holding On

Have you ever noticed how difficult it can be to leave an unresolved question alone? Maybe it's a conversation that didn't go the way you hoped, a decision you're uncertain about, or something happening in a relationship. Sometimes it's simply that nagging feeling that something in your life needs to change, even though you can't quite explain what it is.

You revisit it while driving. You think about it in the shower. It finds its way into those quiet moments before sleep, when you would really rather be thinking about nothing at all. Sometimes you discover something useful. Other times, you're simply walking the same familiar mental path, hoping another trip around will reveal something you missed.

I know that experience well.

What I've come to recognize is that my desire to understand isn't always driven by curiosity. Sometimes it's driven by discomfort. I want the uncertainty to end. I want to know that I've made the right decision, that I've considered everything, and that things will eventually work out.

Underneath all that thinking, I may simply be looking for reassurance. I want to feel safe in a situation where I don't yet know what comes next. That's an important distinction because when we're thinking to understand, our minds can be wonderfully creative. But when we're thinking to eliminate uncertainty, we can become trapped in a conversation with ourselves that has no natural ending.

There will always be another possibility to consider, another outcome to anticipate, or another question to ask. And while we're busy examining all those possibilities, something else can happen. We can become so absorbed in trying to understand our lives that we forget to be present in them.

What My Garden Began Teaching Me

Several years ago, I began creating what I now call my Mind Garden. It started with clearing some overgrown buckthorn in my backyard. What emerged over time was a series of walking paths, including concentric circles and an infinity loop. I hadn't set out to create a place for personal reflection. Initially, I was simply clearing some unwanted vegetation and following an idea that seemed interesting. But as the garden evolved, so did my relationship with it.

I began walking those paths, sometimes with a question on my mind and sometimes simply because I needed to get outside. At first, I approached those walks much as I approached everything else. I brought my questions with me and expected to think through them. After all, wasn't that part of the purpose of having a quiet place to walk?

But over time, I began noticing something interesting. The more I allowed myself to simply walk, the less concerned I became about finding an immediate answer. I would notice the trees, the changing light, the sounds of birds, or the feeling of moving along a familiar path. Sometimes my mind would wander, and sometimes it would become unusually quiet.

A simple path winding through a leafy garden in soft morning light

Occasionally, something I had been struggling to understand would suddenly seem a little clearer. It wasn't always an answer. Sometimes it was simply a different way of looking at the question. I began to realize that these moments weren't happening because I was thinking harder. They seemed to happen when I stopped demanding that my mind produce something useful. I was beginning to discover the difference between creating space to think and creating space to notice. And that distinction has become increasingly meaningful in other areas of my life.

The Difference Between Thinking and Noticing

I certainly don't believe we need to stop thinking. That would be a strange recommendation from someone who has spent a lifetime encouraging learning, reflection, and curiosity. Our ability to reason is extraordinary. It helps us make decisions, understand one another, solve problems, and imagine possibilities that haven't yet existed.

But thinking is only one part of how we come to understand ourselves and the world around us. We also learn through experience, emotion, observation, and those moments when something simply begins to make sense without our having consciously worked through every detail.

Consider someone who has spent weeks trying to decide whether to accept a new professional opportunity. On paper, the decision makes sense. The compensation is better, the responsibilities are greater, and the opportunity looks like a logical next step. Friends and colleagues might even wonder why there's any hesitation.

Yet something doesn't feel quite right.

So, the person creates another list of advantages and disadvantages, seeks more advice, and reexamines the possibilities. Still, the uncertainty remains. What might happen if, instead of asking which choice makes the most sense, that person asked what matters most at this point in life?

Perhaps the answer would be exactly the same. Perhaps the opportunity really is the right next step. But perhaps the hesitation is revealing something that another round of analysis would never uncover.

Maybe the person has changed. Maybe the definition of success that once felt exciting no longer holds the same meaning. Maybe what matters most now is something that doesn't appear on a list of professional advantages.

This is where I see the importance of alignment. Thinking helps us understand our options. Awareness helps us recognize how those options relate to our values, needs, and the person we're becoming. We need both. The challenge is recognizing when we've reached the limits of what more thinking can accomplish.

Changing light falling across a quiet garden path beneath leafy trees

When the Mind Doesn't Need Another Assignment

One of the things I appreciate about meditation is that it continues to challenge my tendency to turn almost everything into a task. Even sitting quietly can become another opportunity to accomplish something. Am I doing this correctly? Should I be feeling more peaceful? Why can't I stop thinking? How much longer until my mind settles?

It's almost amusing when I catch myself doing it. There I am, supposedly practicing stillness, while my mind is working overtime trying to make stillness happen. Over time, I've come to appreciate that meditation isn't about forcing thoughts to disappear. It's more about learning to notice them without feeling obligated to follow every one. A thought arises, I recognize it, and when I remember, I allow it to pass without immediately turning it into another conversation with myself.

Some days that comes easily. Other days, my mind seems determined to hold a committee meeting about everything that has happened in the past week. But even those restless moments have something to offer. They remind me that I don't have to respond to every thought simply because it appears.

I can notice a concern without immediately solving it. I can experience uncertainty without rushing to eliminate it. I can recognize an emotion without requiring myself to explain why it's there. That doesn't mean ignoring problems or avoiding difficult decisions. It means giving myself enough space to understand what's happening before deciding what, if anything, needs to be done. It's a practice I continue to learn, and probably one I'll be practicing for the rest of my life.

The Wisdom of Not Knowing Yet

We live in a world that places enormous value on answers, especially now, when technology can produce information, recommendations, and seemingly confident responses almost instantly. We can ask artificial intelligence to analyze a problem, compare options, identify patterns, and suggest a course of action. These are remarkable capabilities, and I use them myself.

But as these tools become increasingly woven into our lives, I've been thinking about something. Having more answers available doesn't necessarily mean we're asking the questions that matter most. Technology can help us process information, but it cannot determine what gives our lives meaning. It can help us examine possibilities, but it cannot experience our values, relationships, hopes, and uncertainties for us.

Those remain deeply human experiences.

Perhaps as the world becomes increasingly capable of thinking for us, our ability to notice what's happening within us becomes even more important. Not because thinking is less valuable, but because awareness gives our thinking direction. I've come to believe that some of the most important moments in our lives begin when we become willing to acknowledge that we simply don't know yet.

I don't mean using uncertainty as an excuse to avoid responsibility or postpone decisions indefinitely. There are times when we need to act without having all the answers. But there's a difference between avoiding a decision and allowing one to mature. Some questions need time. Some require conversations with people we trust. Others become clearer through experience rather than continued analysis.

And sometimes we need to acknowledge that the discomfort of not knowing is simply part of being human. We don't have to turn every uncertainty into an emergency that demands immediate resolution.

Making Room for What We Already Know

I still think a great deal. I still analyze, anticipate, question, and occasionally spend far too much time revisiting something that probably deserved less attention. I doubt that will change completely, and I'm not sure I would want it to. Curiosity and thoughtful examination are important parts of who I am.

But I'm learning that I don't have to think my way through every experience. Sometimes I need to walk in my garden. Sometimes I need to listen to someone else's perspective. Sometimes I need an honest conversation with someone I trust, not because I expect that person to provide an answer, but because being heard helps me hear myself. And sometimes I simply need to sit quietly long enough to recognize what I've been feeling beneath all the thinking.

The most meaningful change hasn't been learning how to silence my mind. It's been recognizing that my mind doesn't always need to be in charge of the conversation. There's room for thoughtful analysis, and there's room for awareness. There's room for questions that don't yet have answers and experiences that don't need to be immediately explained. Perhaps wisdom isn't always found in thinking more deeply. Sometimes it emerges when we become quiet enough to notice what has been there all along.

Questions Readers Often Ask

How can I tell whether I'm thinking to understand something or trying to eliminate uncertainty?

Thinking to understand may help you see a situation, or your options, more clearly. When thinking is aimed at eliminating uncertainty, it can feel like returning to the same questions without finding a natural stopping point. The distinction may not always be obvious, but noticing what you hope the next round of thinking will give you can be a place to begin.

What does “noticing” mean in practice, and is it the same as meditation?

Noticing can be as simple as paying attention to your breathing, your surroundings, or what you feel when a particular question comes to mind. Meditation can offer a way to practice noticing thoughts without automatically following them, but noticing doesn't have to happen in formal meditation. It can also happen during a quiet walk or an ordinary moment in the day.

Does this mean I should stop analyzing and planning?

No. Thinking and planning can help us make thoughtful decisions and understand our choices. The essay is about making room for awareness alongside analysis, especially when more thinking seems to repeat rather than clarify.

How do I know when a question needs time rather than more analysis?

There may not be a clear signal, and different questions call for different responses. It might be worth noticing whether another round of analysis is bringing new understanding, or whether the question is asking for time, experience, or a conversation with someone you trust. Sometimes the answer becomes clearer as you live with the question.

Still have a question? I'd love to hear what's resonating with you. Feel free to share your thoughts or reach out through Spirit Rising Coaching.


A question to carry with you

Where in your life might you be trying to think your way toward an answer that first needs a little room to emerge? You don't have to answer that immediately, either. Maybe just carry it with you for a while and see what you notice.


A Five-Minute Practice: Notice What You Already Know

If there's something you've been thinking about repeatedly, I'd like to invite you to try a simple experiment. Find five minutes when you can sit quietly or take a slow walk without distractions. Bring to mind whatever question or concern has been occupying your thoughts, but rather than trying to solve it, simply notice what happens.

Pay attention to your breathing, the sensations in your body, and the emotions that arise when you think about the situation. Notice whether you feel anxious, frustrated, hopeful, or perhaps something you hadn't recognized before. You don't need to analyze those feelings or decide what they mean.

After a few minutes, gently ask yourself, "What am I noticing that I've been too busy thinking to recognize?" Then allow the question to rest. You may discover something meaningful, or you may simply experience a few minutes of being present without trying to accomplish anything. Either way, you've practiced something valuable: creating room for awareness rather than demanding an answer.

Continue the Conversation

If this reflection brings something forward, I'd welcome a conversation. You can reach out here whenever it feels right.

— Michael

Stay Connected

Receive Michael’s essays and reflections by email. If someone came to mind, send them a simple invitation to join the list.